Closing Night [TIFF 2026]

A movie that begins by defying its title and continues to defy our expectations of both its story and its characters, this is Cody Fern’s melodramatic directorial debut, Closing Night. Despite its title, the film opens on the opening night of an internationally famed actress’s new Broadway show, as old wounds quickly resurface when she invites her estranged family to the show, breaking a decades-long silence. An achievement of a script by co-writers Cody Fern and Devon Bostick, as well as a phenomenal performance from the lead, Sarah Paulson, supported effortlessly by a shining cast of Naomi Watts, Dianne Wiest, Odessa A’zion, and Toby Wallace, Closing Night is cementing its place as one of the most promising debuts from a filmmaker this year.

Internationally acclaimed actress Sandra (Paulson) is opening her new Broadway show, and her estranged sister, April (Watts), and her nephew (Wallace) receive invitations. This invitation comes after a decades-long silence from the actress, estranged from all of her family. When an incident causes Sandra’s life to begin to unravel, all members of the family begin to fall back into their old habits. As family truths are revealed and this messy family once again finds themselves together, old resentments begin to simmer, threatening to boil over at any moment.

Following his 10-year writing partnership with co-writer of Closing Night, Devon Bostick, director and co-writer Cody Fern makes his directorial debut after years spent in front of the camera. And what a debut it is. It is clear that the person behind the camera knows what it is to be an actor and a writer, bringing his strengths to create a film that is one of the strongest directorial debuts I can remember in recent memory. The performances he inspires in his cast are amazing, and his work with the camera to bring all the moving parts of the film together is astounding.

The way Fern and co-writer Devon Bostick balance the film’s delicate tonal shifts so effortlessly is itself worthy of all the praise it is receiving. One moment you will be bent over laughing, and immediately the next you will be in tears. They are able to capture the ever-shifting emotions within a messy family, constantly transforming resentment to love to anger to bitterness to forgiveness and back again to resentment so quickly. Paired with dialogue that feels real, this ability to so quickly adapt to a changing tone, with the heightened emotions ever present in a melodrama, makes this film a wild ride, where every tear and laugh is fully earned.

The entire script is tight, even though the film seems to somehow include just about every “cliche” storyline. There are so many moving parts of this story, but all of them come together so succinctly that they never drag or feel out of place. Once a storyline is introduced, it never seems to go the way we have come to expect, even the ones that we are sure we have seen done before. The rhythm of the conversations between characters and the movement of the scenes themselves set the film up with wonderful pacing, allowing the players to shine without audiences ever becoming fatigued by an overly drawn-out script, despite how much this film tackles. The script is deeply personal to co-writer Cody Fern, exploring its heavier themes with a delicate hand that is not afraid to confront the harsh truths of the world they live in.

Speaking of the players, Sarah Paulson’s performance in Closing Night has not left my mind since the film concluded yesterday. Dianne Wiest said in the post-screening Q&A that Paulson’s whole career has been leading to this role, and no truer words have ever been spoken. The role plays to all her strengths, especially in the truly melodramatic moments, while still pushing her to explore the more subdued and deeply layered aspects of her complex character. It is a role made for her, that is unforgettable and easily one of the best of the year.

Paulson is also supported by a phenomenal, star-studded cast, including Naomi Watts, Dianne Wiest, Odessa A’zion, and Toby Wallace. They all understand their characters so deeply and are able to find the humanity in these exaggerated characters, especially the phenomenal Wiest as the resentful mother of April and Sandy, who approaches even this bitter character with an understanding heart.

There is a beautiful overall theme throughout the film that asks the question: can old wounds ever truly be healed? What must happen to a person for us to find forgiveness for another’s act? There are so many moving parts to this film’s story, but all of these parts effortlessly converge in the end into something completely new that still brings us back to these original questions. The film’s constant ability to balance its tone and stay on track to tell the singular story of this familial reunion is an amazing achievement, and one that fits perfectly into the genre of a melodrama. Even the music throughout the film, which can feel a bit heavy-handed at times, works to heighten the extreme emotions in the film, with bold camera choices that all contribute to amplifying the very human questions the film asks us.

Sarah Paulson gives the performance of the year in Cody Fern’s directorial debut, Closing Night. Co-written with Devon Bostick, the film will have you laughing one moment and crying the next, completely understanding the wacky dynamics of an estranged family coming back together. Cody Fern is cementing himself here as one to watch, crafting a career-best performance for Paulson, who is supported by a shining cast that continues to defy what we expect from the story until the very end.

Closing Night was screened at the 2026 Toronto International Film Festival. Image courtesy of TIFF.

Sarah Paulson in Closing Night