If you’ve ever wondered what Barney & Friends would be like if Barney were a murderous dictator who would take a kid out for saying “no” to a dance party, then oh boy, does Casper Kelly have a movie for you. In his version, the orange fuzzy unicorn is Buddy, and his latest film, Buddy, tells exactly this story. While the film most definitely subverts expectations and completely dives headfirst into the deep end of parodying this kind of children’s show, it is, in the end, a very specific type of humor that is needed to fully enjoy the film, in what seems to be a film that is just a 90-minute-too-long, too-insensitive SNL sketch.
Buddy is a plush toy unicorn who comes alive when the children in his playhouse call, “Hey, Buddy!” When one child refuses to dance with the others, Buddy kills him off-screen before the other children join in song and the episode ends. As the other children begin to catch on and realize they must escape this murderous orange unicorn, there is clearly more than meets the eye in Buddy’s world. As realities start to crack and the children’s true origins are slowly revealed, realities converge as the children try to escape, not knowing where they came from.
Buddy is a film that knows what it is. An SNL skit meets creepypasta meets Robot Chicken; it is a movie that takes an adult horror spin on a childhood fear. How often did we look back at Barney or other children’s shows as pre-teens and think, wow, that was kind of creepy? Now, as an adult who can make art, director and writer Casper Kelly can make films from this adult lens about the absurdities of the media we consumed as kids. Even down to the silly fake jingles we would sing to the real melodies, these are all purposefully included in this horror comedy spoof.
In this horror-comedy, the film leans more into the comedy side. Aside from one moment in the film featuring a jump scare, there was not anything scary that kept me up at night. There are some disturbing body horror elements, if you can call it that when the “body” is a furry mascot. But once again, these more horrific images of Buddy are taken to the next level when it is revealed that there isn’t a “guy in the suit” but instead flesh and organs within what we would expect to be just a costume.
Going along with the disturbing images, the main premise of the film being a depiction of violence against children kept me from ever fully wanting to get on board with the film. Sure, it is a strange parody that we have all at some point joked about; what if the creepy mascot is actually just that… a creep! But to make a film whose whole “thing” is actually showing gory and disturbing images of children being killed in the name of parody, then I do struggle to see why this needed to be made with such a disturbing focus on violence against children in the name of entertainment. Other themes are presented that could have had something to say against this violence, but it is all thrown out the window by the third act.
This is not to say I am anti-every horror movie that features violence against children. But films like It (2017) or Weapons (2025) use this violence and our own discomfort with the images to make a larger commentary on things like generational trauma or violence in schools today. When violence against children in films seems to only exist for adult comedy and entertainment, I struggle with it as I do in Buddy.
The first act of the film is something unique. We watch episode after episode of It’s Buddy, as the children start to fear their furry friend. In their search for a trusted adult through the vast no man’s land outside of Buddy’s playground, reality starts to crack, and the second act adds in a more grounded story. The story is of a mother of two in a different reality who believes she has three children, but cannot seem to remember the third one at all. She discovers this television show, one with an orange unicorn, but she cannot find anything about it online. When the film tries to bring all of these aspects together, it just does not work, and the third act has to choose what direction to take. A choice between a deeper exploration of this idea about missing children and predation, or making more jokes about how crazy that unicorn is. Unfortunately, for myself at least, they make the wrong decision, and we are left with a 20-minute battle scene with a monster brutally killing children.
This is all to say that the film is simply trying to do too much. Sure, it knows what it is as a comedic parody, but as a dramatic horror film, it struggles to know what it wants to say, or if it even wants to say anything at all. As a result, it feels like it does not fully explore any idea it presents, and instead reaches for the easy finale of a bloody battle and chase scene that has a rather obvious result.
If this kind of comedy is for you, for example a children’s mascot calling a kid a “bitch”, then sure, see the film. But I also do not know how well this film will play once it leaves theatres, as I think many of these stupid jokes land much better in a packed theatre, when you can all laugh at the absurdity of what you’re watching together.
On the positive, some amazing child performances show a lot of promise in both comedy and horror. The film does hinge on the kids capturing the horror of the film without showing an awareness of the absurdity of it all, and they do it well. Keegan-Michael Key’s voice as Buddy the Unicorn is also booming, perfectly balancing the creepy with the sweet and capturing the unease that throws us off when we revisit our old favourite children’s media.
If you’re into absurd horror comedies with ridiculous body horror and can turn your brain off for 90-minutes, then sure, maybe Buddy is for you. But for myself, who struggles with nonsensical depictions of child murder for adult comedic entertainment, I would say stick to the kind real-life purple dinosaur and leave Casper Kelly’s Buddy in your own list of unwatched films.
Buddy will be released in theatres in Canada on August 28. Image courtesy of Mongrel Media.


