Big Girls Don’t Cry

As the sound of the dial-up internet begins to play and loud keyboards are anxiously tapped, waiting for a connection to the online chat, we find Sid. 14-year-old New Zealander who will do anything to be in with the pretty popular girls. It is a story we may think we have seen before, a coming-of-age that sounds so familiar. But Paloma Schneideman’s feature film debut has something new to offer to this genre of films, something that queers the narrative in a subtle way that will be recognized by so many viewers who have experienced a similar upbringing, no matter if they grew up during this very specific time in the early 2000s, or in a completely different generation.

Sid spends her days arguing with her father at home, waiting for her sister to return, or on the internet at her only friend’s house. Trying to get in with the cool girls who spend their free time on Omaha’s beaches, Sid messages one of them through her friend’s older brother’s Messenger account. When summer begins with her older sister returning home from university with her new American friend, she finds a way in with the popular girls when her sister agrees to drive her to Omaha. Wanting to become just like the popular girls, while also feeling attraction towards them that she may not understand, Sid struggles to maintain her past relationships as she discovers part of who she is during her 14th summer.

The film hinges on a believable performance reeking of second-hand embarrassment, as any good coming-of-age film does. Ani Palmer, who plays Sid, is extraordinary in this role, creating a very real character that we can all see glimpses of our old selves in. I was skeptical before watching this film, knowing that Rain Spencer was co-starring, the only name I recognized attached to the film, who I did not find particularly promising in the series The Summer I Turned Pretty. But I am glad that this did not turn me away from the film, as she is much stronger here than in the series and plays the role of the fun friend of the older sister well, while Palmer truly carries the film from the start and has chemistry with all the other players, perfecting the awkward tension between 14-year-olds.

The film is already being talked about as the queer coming-of-age film we never had. While this is true, I appreciated that the film was a more general story about a young woman growing up rather than a specific story of a young woman coming out. It is clear that Sid is coming to understand her attraction to the girls around her, but the film feels very real, with the director never forcing Sid to grow up too soon. Sid comes to realizations at a pace that feels realistic. The film knows that Sid will not discover all the world’s secrets in this 90-minute movie, but instead it leaves the audience with enough to know these realizations will come with time. Yes, Big Girls Don’t Cry is a queer self-discovery film, but at its core it is a simpler coming-of-age film that will be appreciated by all, with just the right amount of growing up occurring in one summer so that the story remains realistic.

I was often reminded of the film Dìdi when watching Big Girls Don’t Cry. Two films so deeply settled in a specific time period in the 2000s that explore general themes of coming-of-age, while each also caters to a more specific demographic. Like Chris’s experiences as a Taiwanese American in Dìdi, Sid’s coming of age that includes recognizable markers of a queer kid who may not yet fully understand their desires is important to be shared on screen, making visible the experiences of so many 20 to 30-somethings now. Both films keep their stories quite simple and by the books, but still feel complex in the themes they tackle and the recognizable characters they create that have often been left out of the coming-of-age narrative.

Paloma Schneideman’s feature debut offers something new to the coming-of-age film. Her film Big Girls Don’t Cry queers the narrative in an inventive way. Instead of telling the story of a coming out, she builds her character Sid around the moments us queer adults look back on and now recognize as queer. Wanting to be the cool popular girl, without realizing it was a crush. Being jealous of the older girls with boyfriends, not realizing we secretly wished to be on the receiving end. The film does not reinvent the coming-of-age arc, but it has something special to add, set in a small town in New Zealand where we will all see ourselves throughout Sid’s story.

Big Girls Don’t Cry will be released in select theatres in Canada on October 9. Image courtesy of Blue Fox Entertainment.

Big Girls Don’t Cry